#American*

As the daughter of immigrants, Angie Chuang saw how you could have it all and still not belong. Her fatherâa civil engineerânever felt trulyĚýincluded in this country, a struggle Chuang frequently reflected on, even as her own career has taken off.
âMy father was an American success storyâa civil engineer at Lawrence Livermore National Lab,â said Chuang, an associate professor of journalism. âBut seeing his struggles as I grew up made me profoundly aware of what it meant to be American with an asterisk.â
Her personal and professional experienceâincluding covering race and ethnic issues atĚýThe Oregonian and developing curricula around related topics at both American University and CMDIâhas given her a unique perspective when it comes to the news mediaâs struggles in reporting on race. Itâs a topic she explores thoroughly in a new book, American Otherness in Journalism: News Media Representations of IdentityĚýand Belonging.
The book would have been published years ago, but as she was completing her first draft in 2016, Donald Trump was riding a wave of white nationalism to the White House, requiringĚý
important revisions.
âI didnât feel it would be principled, as a researcher, to not consider the radical shift in thinking heĚýrepresented,â she said.
ĚýThere hasn't been equal access granted to who gets to say their unfiltered version of events to the press.âĚý
Angie Chuang, associate professor, journalism
In its new iteration, half the book investigates how news media has historically represented people, whileĚýthe second half looks at how the president has dominated that narrative, in many ways narrowing the definitionĚýof âAmerican.â
Itâs not a new problemâChuang covers examples like the infamous âAmerican beats out Kwanâ headline from the 1990s and coverage of Virginia Tech shooter Seung-Hui Choâbut Trumpâs rhetoric intrigued herĚý
as a researcher, because while he was clearly talking aboutĚýrace, he rarely used traditional code words.
For example, early reports after the Charlottesville Unite the Right rally used phrases like âalt-right,â âpro-whiteâ and, sparingly, âwhite nationalismâ because those were the terms those individuals used to describe themselves. When pressed, Trump referred to them as âvery fine people.â
âJournalismâs fundamental flaw is that âobjective journalismâ has taught people to get their sourcesâ perspectives and reproduce them in an unbiased, unfiltered way so the reader can decide,â Chuang said. âWhat weâve learned is that there hasnât been equal access granted to who gets to say their unfiltered version of events to the press.â
But she has hope. Thanks in part to public pushback challenging the âobjectiveâ earlier reporting, The Associated Press has directed journalists to use more definitive terms like âwhite supremacistâ and even âracist.â
And as younger, diverse reporters emerge in the media landscape, bringing journalism to new placesâlike TikTok and SubstackâChuang sees the opportunity to make journalism better and more accessibleĚýby reflecting the stories andĚýconcerns of diverse communities.
âI donât think we have to be precious about the wordĚýâjournalism.â And journalismĚýdoes check itself; itâs not a monolith,â she said. âIâmĚýinterested in journalism having these debates and trying to do better, even in the face of attacks from the federal government. Journalism scholars and industry leaders need to continually push and advocate for free speech and responsible reporting.â
Hannah Stewart graduated from CMDI in 2019 with a degree in communication. She covers student news for the college.